Lillie - A study of Faith
biography, non-fiction, mental hospitals, spirituality
Published on:
August 8, 5:04pmWord Count:
1356Work Description
This woman spent her adult years in a State Mental Hospital while completely sane because of a snafu regarding laws at that time.
This work is archived and isn't accepting critiques or comments. Why?
Print
Being alone, truly and completely alone, should not be a burden carried by a human being for long. I’m not sure we were born for it. Our lives are such fragile existences just as they are – it only takes one blow to unhinge the mechanisms which hold us together. There are few who can survive for long in such conditions. I was lucky to have known such a woman, one who had survived essentially alone in a cacophony of insanity for fifty years.
My mother was a charge nurse at Wingdale State Hospital in Wingdale, New York. It was a facility where the crazies and mentally handicapped were housed until the 1970’s when the government dismantled these facilities and dumped most of the inpatients onto the streets. Mom worked in the wards for the elderly insane women. It was there she met Lillie.
Lillie was in her seventies when Mom discovered her. She was in a general ward – a huge room where twenty women were housed – all bedridden. These women were certifiable. They rocked in their beds . . . moaning, crying, or screaming – never silent. They clutched toy dolls to their chests, hollow remembrances of children who no longer visited or never were. Their matted, tangled hair hung strangled down their back. The aroma of urine seeped into your pores when you were there, its reek steeped in the air, always stronger than any antiseptic could cover. You can’t imagine the din. It was awesome, ferocious, never ending.
When she was twenty-eight, Lillie immigrated from Sweden to marry the love of her life. Two weeks after the wedding, he dropped dead for an aneurism. In shock, she suffered a nervous breakdown and was committed to Wingdale where she began the slow process of piecing herself back together. However, the state of New York had a catch-twenty law in place . . . once admitted to a state hospital, only a relative who could sponsor her could check her out. All Lillie’s relatives were, unfortunately, in Sweden. She was trapped.
For years she worked in maintenance and housekeeping, cleaning out bed pans and washing floors. The state had a cheep source of slave labor. It certainly wasn’t glamorous but it filled her days. It was a tentatively workable solution until she fell and broke her hip.
During her convalescence, arthritis set into her body. Suddenly bedridden, she had to draw on inner resources to survive. But she took it a step further and fell back on her spirituality. Her faith was awe inspiring. It was dynamic and fluid. You could not witness it and fail to be changed in ways small or profound. The staff seemed undeterred by the love which radiated from her spirit but those she met through my mother came away inspired. They believe more because she did and it was inconceivable that she could have such a strong spiritual foundation in the face of such adversity.
And adversity it surely was. My Mom started working at the “hospital” as a charge nurse when Lillie had been an inmate for about fifty years. My Mom didn’t stay long at Wingdale. She was horrified by the unspeakable conditions in which these women existed. Care was demeaning, depersonalized and cruel. Bed sores abounded, some breaking down to the bone. When showers were given, it was on steel beds under ice cold water. Patients lay in their own filth for far too long. Food was withheld as a means of punishment and control. Aides ran the floor as the nurse sat behind the desk knitting. There was absolutely no positive stimulation, no television or radio, no music, no programs to look forward to, no sane voices; just the unending screaming and crying of the patients both day and night. It was in this environment Lillie passed her days, in complete sanity. When she met Mom, she had been bedridden for ten years. Her body a host to her faith and grace.
Mom started bringing me and a few of her friends to visit Lillie. At first I was uncomfortable, especially when she was in the general ward where so many were housed in the same room, but after meeting her, my attitude changed. We would bring some sweets and snacks, books, a radio. The radio brought her contact with the world outside her four walls for the first time since she was admitted fifty years
Rate This Work
Discussion
This is definitely an important topic to write about. It's one of many atrocities that exist, almost in secret, throughout society. It's important for people to understand the conditions that were prevalent in 'mental institutions' during the hundreds of years they were in operation, and may still exsist today.
I particularly like your description because it has a personal touch. It is informative without sounding like a public serice announcement. This story, which I can only assume is a true story, makes the reader want to continue reading it even though the early parts may be too disturbing and turn some people off.
Your writing style is very easy to follow and has an informal feel to it that adds to the emotion of the story. Your diction and description are great and I wouldn't change any of it. I do think that you could enhance it with a little more detail regarding Lillie's faith.
You could not witness it and fail to be changed in ways small or profound.
It would be nice if you had a specific example to illustrate how strong her faith really was.
The rest of my comments are more 'line-by-line' specific.
It was a facility where the crazies and mentally handicapped were housed...
I don't like the use of the word 'crazies'. Not because I think it is offensive but because it is slang that doesn't fit in with remainder of your writing style.
The aroma of urine seeped into your pores when you were there, its reek steeped in the air, always stronger than any antiseptic could cover.
This is very descriptive in a good way. It really provides the reader with a detailed picture of the ward.
There is no way I can completely convey the atmosphere of the open ward...
I think you did an excellent job of conveying the atmosphere at the beginning of the writing. I think that by adding this line you not only give the reader a reason to agree with you but your hurried description that follows...
. . .row after row of hospital beds, toothless old crones strapped to their beds, holding dirty cloth dolls, caterwauling at ear-splitting din.. They were all in hospital gowns with stringy hair and vacant eyes above mouths that either cried or raged or moaned.
...is repetive of what you already said and is not as good as your
previous descriptions.
Other than parts of the final paragraph I really liked this work. Because it is so short I don't know how you could get more people exposed to it. It's too bad because it's something that people who are not a part of this Scribophile community should read.
i enjoyed this piece and I love the perspective. The one thing that I feel like it lacks, however, is Lillie herself. i feel like there needs to be some dialog in here wherein we actually hear Lillie speak. It's wonderful to tell us about a person. It's even better to let us meet the person for ourselves. I think if you did that then you as the writer would no longer bear the burden of convincing us of her great faith. All you would have to do would be juxtapose the person of Lillie with your vivid descriptions of the ward. Also, maybe you could write about your impressions of the ward as a child. How did it seem to you then? And also some physical description of the people, your Mom, Lillie, would be a good idea. Just some thoughts. Good start though.



From a content perspecitve, I love this, but you've got a couple of word choice issues. Seriously though, this is kind of amazing...Both the writing itself and the story it tells.
Undeterred would imply that she's trying to use it to keep them away. If that's not the case, you may want another word, like "unmoved".
If it happened, then it's not really inconceivable. Perhaps it would be more accurate to say that it "seemed" inconceivable, or "because they couldn't conceive how".
Did you mean to repeat this?