Ignorant Treason
Actions
poetry
1st
Draft
Published on:
February 23, 7:26amWord Count:
113Work Description
A poem I wrote during a messy breakup I just couldn't drop
This work is archived and isn't accepting critiques or comments. Why?
Page: 1
Print
Words older than us, and my
ignorant treason,
----Feigning verses of a feigning
love,
Still ring true in our love’s
stagnant season,
----This bygone adoration I’m a
captive of,
The mouth that spoke your love to
me,
Turns around and shows it to
another’s lips,
This tired heart has been through
this before,
And my tongue knows these vacant
scripts,
So come with me and we will take
our walk
Into the crisp embrace of the
night,
Dark beaches and empty
streets,
Illuminated by far flung star
light,
You’ll carry the
conversation,
While I carry the load,
Because though I am with
you,
I still walk a lonely road.
Page: 1
Rate This Work
Discussion
I think that the decision to stick to a rhyme scheme hurts your
intent in this piece. There are certainly some good ideas present
but I feel they are obscured by a desire to appear more literate,
or more relevant - if that makes sense. I think that sometimes
honesty is sacraficed in favour of embellishment, and in the case
of this piece, I think the latter is winning out over the former.
It may seem like I'm putting a lot of analysis on such a short
piece but I think that the feeling and the idea here are valid, but
that you are being hung up with notions of what "should" and
"should not" be present in a piece of work. I feel like there is
probably something rather interesting to be said here, but it is
being obscured by the desire to expand depth where simplicity would
serve just as well. Sometimes it is best to be simple, even if it
means sacraficing a metaphor or two - the key to honest writing is
honest communication, and sometimes that can be compromised by
focusing too hard on the language and not hard enough on the
message.



Lovely work.
My favorite phrases: love's stagnant season; bygone adoration; my tongue knows these vacant scripts.
I appreciate your use of structure and rhyme scheme, both underused in modern poetry. You have done an excellent job of encapsulating your feelings into these words. I have a great admiration for this, as I tend to be a thinking, more than a feeling, writer.
What could be improved? I believe that the poem might work better if you transposed the first two stanzas with the second two. Right now the poem starts with words and abstraction and then moves into the concrete of the walk. If it started with the invitation to walk then the reader has a physical place/sensation to start of with, important in such a short work. My first read through I didn't really get captured until the third stanza, even though the best writing (in my opinion) is in the first two. Also, those second two stanza are almost too right as a conclusion. As if you thought, here's a good way to wrap it up. If you ended with the vacant scripts line I believe that you would be leaving your reader in the same open-ended space that the poem is referencing.
Overall, it is really well done. You can certainly turn a poetic phrase, a skill I admire. While the sentiment itself is genuine, it has been the subject of countless poems. This puts you in with some fierce competition for the mind of your reader. Perhaps a longer version could tread some new ground.