« Back to Joshua Allen Tompkins's profile
All Critiques and Comments
Showing 17 of 32 critiques and comments.
On Sam, Chapter 1: January 1, 2006, by Monsterbox: So a dip into the steak filled bathtub for a moment, hm? There's
definetely a long loving look at psychopathy here, but I... » Read more...
On The Rainy Day, by Hans Roh: ...I tumbled out of this twisted piece like falling out of a bad
dream, the ones that come on hard but never leave any trace ... » Read more...
On Disc Love, by Emma Larkins: Hey Emma,
Telling tales is a tricky business, and sometimes it takes a
little bit of leg to get the distance out of the yarn ... » Read more...
On Grave Decisions, by Laurie Paulsen: Hey Laurie,
I had to laugh at this piece since I can clearly remember living
in a far too haunted farm house and dealing quit... » Read more...
On Darkness of birth, by Emily Bransby-Schurmann: Hey Emily,
Essentially I took this poem as a heart-song; it has the rolling
lilt of a simple song winding down through ... » Read more...
On Hill's 4th Harmony, Chapter 1, by Brian Mattocks: Hey Brian,
I think it was premature to make a serious attempt at critque
with this piece as it in the birthing stages at this... » Read more...
On A Visionary's Vision, by James Barger: Hey James,
Bits and pieces of this one fall into place for me the more that
I read it; I'm coming to believe that it shou... » Read more...
On Every Saint Has a Past Every Sinner Has a Future, Chapter 1: Prologue, by SilentWriter: Punching through this took some time, mulling over the
details....
While the theme of the work shows up throughout, the heavy... » Read more...
On Show Me, by a.mscifi: I liked reading through this, but I have to say it's so hard for
me to look at lyrics without the framework of the music ... » Read more...
On Flicker, by Christine C:
My breath grazes the candle’s flame.
It struggles, in its last moment,
to live and to die.
I pulled from this line in loo... » Read more...
On Tonight, Tomorrow, by Christine C: ...I have to say that this is a powerful combination of imagery
from the start, with a good hook to it, that seems to ask mos... » Read more...
On Caught You, by Circus: Hey Circus,
For an experiment in free verse, this is a very polished piece,
with just a hint of jumpiness to it that maybe ju... » Read more...
On Good Enough for Me, by dreamchaser: Opening Comments
...this piece has a very honest feel to it, almost the way you'd
write a note and leave it on a pillow ... » Read more...
On In the Face of the Dead, by Richard Rowell: ....Reading through the piece, I have to agree with most of what
was said by everybody else; the message is clear and central... » Read more...
On The Great Divide, by Cody Morales: Touching on these poems left my mouth dry in some way, very
palpably feeling the dissaffected way that relationships can work... » Read more...
On This Night, by xjruss: This Night:
Sometimes, the need to make something seem more like a poem can
get in the way of the poem itself, and in this ca... » Read more...
On Untitled Fantasy Fiction, by Nafeesa: Hey Nafeesa,
I'm brand new to the community here, and I was naturally
searching out some of the writing that's somewh... » Read more...




