How Come Kanaka
This work is archived and isn't accepting critiques or comments. Why?
Print
Rate This Work
Discussion
First off, I can relate quite a bit to this article being an Alaskan Native and having lived in Hawaii for a year during college. The message is quite clear and it was easy to read, with a few exceptions dealing with commas (though that might just be your writing style). One sentence in particular was a bit bumpy in regard to general flow:
She was deposed by Sanford Dole and his haoles backed up by the United States marines and, overwhelmed, reluctantly gave up.
She was forcibly deposed by a joint effort between Sanford Dole, his haoles and the United States Marines. Given the overwhelming influence of her opposition she reluctantly succumbed.
The other paragraph that was a bit tricky was the one beginning with:
True kanakas live by a unique ethic.
I think you make a VERY strong point in this section, but it was kind of lost with the number of breaks the overall structure. The fact that due to the nature of the kanaka's ethic they were ripped of by the less-moral haole kind.
Great work, hope to read more from you!
-pynguin
I initially wrote this as a mini-blog to my six sons who are scattered about the country and keep in touch by email. It was written in response to their queries and sort of in "pidgin-ese". The critiques thus far are very valid and appreciated. I will revise my original computer file accordingly. Thank you, Pyngyn and Amber Lynn (Incidentally, Amber Lynn also is the name of my grand-daughter).
Hello, Leroy Dumont. I have to say, this Aloha! And also, I would like to say that this had really related to me because I went to Hawaii and I watched a show that focused on Hawaiian cultures called Lilo and Stitch, which actaully was a cartoon show. When I watch the show, sometimes it will make me think about going back to Hawaii and hearing the song that Elvis Presley (I think he may have sang this before, I do not know exactly) called Aloha Oe. This was a great work that you shared with us, Leroy. I look forward to reading more of your works! Take care!



Starting here, I think this line could use it's own paragraph because you are making a point. A new line is like pounding your fist on the table, saying, "However, kanaka...."
I love this line but what if one doesn't have testicles? Can they still be kanaka? Just kidding.
I like the piece, as a general rule. But...Sorry, gotta go there. You talk about kanaka attitude, but this piece seems to be missing some. It's more of a tell all, which is simply about word choice. Is there a better word for "gave up", "deposed", etc. I like to imagine this piece, although non-fiction, like a man doing an Adam Sandler attitude dialogue. Even non-fiction needs voice and tone.
Other than that, great job. Hope to read more, perhaps chapter 2 from Scorpion Soup? Just wondering...
--Amber