Scribophile

Clemency

Actions
Bookmarking
Remove these ads
compassion, war
3rd
Draft

Published on:

May 6, 9:26pm

Word Count:

156

Last Edited:

May 7, 5:00pm

Work Description

This is meant to illustrate compassion. Does it read that way?

This work is archived. This work is archived and isn't accepting critiques or comments.  Why?
Page: 1
Print WorkPrint

 


The sun was too bright. Lying on his back, he could only squint up at the man standing over him.

"Are you all right?"

"What do you mean?" It wasn’t that he didn’t understand the question; it was just that he couldn’t believe the nescience.

All around him were remnants of a helicopter, his six fallen comrades. What little remains after an explosion.

With help, he stood. He was a big man. With broad shoulders ample enough to carry the weight of the war.

It just happened.

The only one to see the missile, dread filled his soul. It was locked onto them; it couldn’t be shaken.

Nehemiah made a decision.

Moving to an empty seat in the chopper, he blocked their view.

No one saw it coming.

Not even him.

And then he awoke in sunlight.

Bearing no outward wound, he walked away from the wreckage. Inaugurated into a new brotherhood.
 

Page: 1
Rate This Work

Your honest rating will help the author improve, and you'll earn a little karma too.

Please log in to rate.

Discussion

 First of all, nescience is my new favorite word. Yes, I had to look it up.

This was intriguing, but a little confusing. I think my major issue was the tense shift. I understand the past tense parts are from the crash and the present tense parts are from.. the present. It just struck me as somewhat confusing. Maybe put the past tense as flashbacks? In italics or something? Maybe it's just me.

I want to tell you, though, that I really like your writing style. In general, I mean; not just this piece. It's so.. specific. And different. And I really enjoy it.

This critique applies to the 1st draft of this work.

Thanks for your comments! I struggled with the tenses too. I had it all past tense, then changed it... I"ll change it back...  I hope it makes the transition smooth....

 

thanks again!

Louise

This critique applies to the 1st draft of this work.

  That helped. Just the fact that it started in past tense made it significantly easier to read; I'm not sure why. But when you get to the line "He'd been the only one to see the missile," you switch to past participle - which, I think, is what you should do. But then you switch back to past. I think the whole part about the crash, all the flashback part, should be in past participle.

He'd been the only one to see the missile. Dread had filled his soul. It had been locked onto them; it couldn't be shaken. Nehemiah had made a decision. Moving to an empty seat, he'd blocked their view. No one saw it coming. Not even him.

And then keep the rest in past tense.  Read back over the whole thing, but insert the past participle and see if it makes sense? Maybe I'm just reading too much into it..

Also, one more thing:

"He was a big man. With broad shoulders ample enough to carry the weight of the war." I like the idea behind that, the war being carried on his broad shoulders. I think the sentences should be combined and separated by a comma, though.

This critique applies to the 2nd draft of this work.

thanks so much. I added a couple of phrases that I think takes care of it! ...I hope...

 

Louise

 You asked if your work demonstrated compassion, and I think it does, just in a different way than what I would usually associate it with. The main obstacle for me was that this piece wasn't very clear, and I couldn't tell if this was an extension of an earlier work or a totally independent one.

I think some adjectives could benefit from more descriptive and fitting words; for example,

The sun was too bright.

Instead of "too bright," perhaps use "glaring," some other adjective. The fact that he had to squint to look up at the man tells us that it is too bright in itself.

I don't like the word nescience, because I think merely using the word "ignorant" would suffice.

There seems to be some incomplete sentences, such as:

All around him were remnants of a helicopter, his six fallen comrades. What little remains after an explosion.

He was a big man. With broad shoulders ample enough to carry the weight of the war.

The only one to see the missile, dread filled his soul.

...he walked away from the wreckage. Inaugurated into a new brotherhood.

 To me, they detract from the dramatic tension of the work.

Finally, I would like to see some elaboration between these lines:

Not even him.

And then he awoke in sunlight.

Perhaps you can mention his own thoughts, his memories; what he's thinking, how he feels about his comrades, his own compassion (whether he calls it that or not)...

To me, despite changes in tense, I still don't fully understand the entire meaning of this work. If there were more thoughts, emotions, inner character, I would feel more of a connection to the main character.

Remove these ads