Scribophile

Questions

Actions
Bookmarking
Remove these ads
july contest, poetry, personal, spiritual
1st
Draft

Published on:

July 3, 7:56pm

Word Count:

144

Work Description

Pondering the meaning of life. Written for the July Contest.

This work is archived. This work is archived and isn't accepting critiques or comments.  Why?
Page: 1
Print WorkPrint

As I wander on the sand,
watching waves crash on the shore
I wonder why I wandered here
and what exactly I’m here for

Every person has a purpose;
every action has an aim.
So the reason that I wandered
must have a focus just the same.

The velvet sky hung lower still
against the raging purple sea—
a dark thought tiptoed in my mind
what if I had no destiny?

Could life just be an empty beach?
Lonely footsteps in the sand,
until the sea swallows even those—
was that what life had to demand?

But no, a single star appeared
in the overbearing black.
If I had faith, a dream, my hopes,
if I had life
what could I lack?

I wondered on one moonless night
and got a revelation—
every being has their meaning
from first breath to last sensation.

Page: 1
Rate This Work

Your honest rating will help the author improve, and you'll earn a little karma too.

Please log in to rate.

Discussion

 I noticed this poem has been entered for the July contest, congratulations, but you might want to fine-tune or tweak it in place for more clarity. Here are some suggestions for stanza one:

"As I wander on the sand,
watching waves crash on the shore
I wonder why I wandered here
and what exactly I’m here for"

Consider these minor tweaks:

"...watching waves crash against the shore;

I wonder why I wandered here;

Exactly what is it am I  looking for?"

Maybe you want to use a thesaurus and check out a couple of other verbs for "wander."

You can get more verve out of that third stanza, especially the last two lines,  try something like this:

"A dark thought invaded my mind -

What if for me, there is no destiny?"

In Stanza three, try using a simile in the first line and moving the question mark to the second line:

"Could life for me be like an empty beach

With lonely footsteps in the sand

Could it mean the sea will swallow even those

To satisfy my life's great demand?"

I hope this helped and again, congratulations and good luck!!

Shilohx7

 

 

 

 

 

 

Opening Comments

  Hello, well this is my first critique of a poem, so bear with me...

Themes

  i could easily understad this poem, i agree waith what ure saying about being put here without a destiny....

Moods

 the mood of this poem was the most interesting part of the poem for me... it had a kind of sorrow-mellow feel, or at least thats what i felt when i was reading it...

Imagery

 The part about the beach really caught my attention and reminded me of a poem that one of my friends wrote, but u took a different turn than her and to be honest i like yours more than hers, dont tell her i said that...

Closing Comments

 Well, i have to say this isnt one of my best critiques and i dont like how u have to critique poems, its really complicated.... and next time i critique a poem im goin gto use the other type of critiqueing. So i guess i have u to thank for helping me figure this out... Well sorry that my critique is bad ill browse ure works and write a better one on a different work of yours. I believe that u should not change a thing, i think its awesome the way it is...

Themes

 I love your use of emotion, which can often be a sticky point for alot of writers whose themes can be common or thought through. With such an emotive piece it is essential to just let the words flow, which is what you have done so I commend you on this.

Remember however, that all the same, when writing whether through flow or thought process, you need to watch and make sure that readers are able to follow it along as freely as you have put pen to paper.

Rhyme and Meter

The rhyming that you have used is brilliant, especially in terms of your usage of larger words rather then those that we most commonly spring to mind when trying to make it roll all together.

I myself often stumble with rhyming and know that it is often a fight between wanting to rhyme and not wanting to overshadow the overall meaning of the works by making it too complicated.

Therefore .. well done in this case !

Diction

re: '... I wonder why I wandered here ...'

I agree with Shiloh in her critique, that your choice of words may need to be tweeked just a little, as the use of words in one line that appear to be the same can sometimes distract from the overall meaning that you are trying to portray.

As sometimes something so little can spark a readers mind so much and take away from the beauty of the overall works.

Read through it, and regain the feeling that you had when you wrote this piece and consider other ways of portraying just what it is that you are putting forth.

Closing Comments

I so look forward to reading more of your works, as perhaps we have much in common in terms of writing themes. You as I have a lot of growth before us and I trust that your pieces will grow as you do. Well done !

 I have to say that this is one of my favorite poems that I've read on here so far. Then imagry was really well as well as the concept. The concept that you were trying to portray if Im not mistaken is pretty much being lost in the world and wondering if you belong which I have felt so its good it see a poem about it.

 The poem is executed well' however, it is an overdone subject.  An overdone subject may make the poem seem trite if it is obvious prima facie.  It reminds me of the existentialist philosophy of Albert Camus or Jean-Paul Sartre.  The image of the beach works well as imagery representing the unknown an inspiring the main theme.

 

Hello Natalie,

Your rhyming and diction is good, except the tenses get mixed: "As I wander", "why I wandered", and "Could life just be", "was that what life had". . .  I commend you on your attempt to bring an old subject to light. But, I'm sorry, I definitely agree with Michael B., this poem is trite. In order for anyone now to write a poem, or prose, on this subject matter: Existentialist philosophy, the author had better skew it with a unique focus.

Perhaps you might begin with the loss of a close loved one: mother, husband, sister, whatever; comment on how you actually, inwardly hated that person, although in all outward appearances you have shown nothing but love. But now you've an epiphany and know you love. . .blah, blah --you get the idea, I'm sure. Just give the whole concept a different view, then maybe the reader may relate to the emotion(s) you reflect in the poem. . .?

~Kirsten

 

 

 

I like this poem overall, but in a couple of places the metre or "poetic" feel of the piece kind of disappear.

As I wander on the sand,
watching waves crash on the shore
I wonder why I wandered here

and what exactly I’m here for

The first three lines here are fine (I, at least, like wonder/wander), but the last has almost no metre to it whatsoever, which is really distracting and throws the reader out of the sense of poetry. 

Every person has a purpose;
every action has an aim.
So the reason that I wandered
must have a focus just the same.

I absolutely love the first two lines!  The third line has no real problems, but the fourth line is just a beat too long and throws off the sense of rhythm (maybe change to "needs a focus just the same"?)

I realize that this is free verse, so my critiques are perhaps not so sensible.  However, I think you do a good job of establishing some sort of ryhtm and metre even though it's free verse, and so it's really hard to get past those lines without it.  Lines like "every action has an aim" or "I wonder why I wandered here" have some really lovely sounds to them, so it's a shame to see them pressed up against ho-hum conversational lines like "and what exactly I'm here for"

All the rest of the things I was going to say are in the same grain, so I'll stop talking here and leave you in peace.


Remove these ads