The War of the Angels
novel, angels, science fiction, young adult
Published on:
May 19, 1:03pmWord Count:
44676Work Description
Where do I begin? I have always needed someone to sit down and read this. I understand it is a full-fledged book, but I really need some feedback on this. I have been fretting over if I should publish this on here, if it was too long, or too soon. However, I have decided. I shall put this on here. I would love for someone to read this and get back to me. Please, enjoy: The War of the Angels
This work is archived and isn't accepting critiques or comments. Why?
Print
Prologue
The moon wasn’t out, and it was a cold and dark night. In addition, the intoxicating smells of leaves were everywhere. Ethan was taking in their sweet aroma as he was running as fast as his legs could take him, away from them.
As he crossed into the woods, he could hear the shouts behind him. Had he made a mistake? Was everything he’d done horribly wrong? It seemed that way to him. After all, these men had hunted him and his “family” for years.
On the other hand, was it all a dream? He didn’t know. However, what he did know was that he had to get away from here as quick as he could. If he could just get to a clearing….his white, smooth and feathery wings would do the rest. Very few still had them.
The men had hunted them too. They had killed most of them. They were his brothers and his family. Everyone he cared about. He hated the men with such a strong feeling; it tore him up inside sometimes. However, he thought, no time to think about that now.
The leaves’ sweet aroma continued to grow as he ran. He watched as trees flew past him like wildfire. He knew that he was getting close. All he had to do… He hoped everyone was ok.
Yet, he was Ethan. He knew what he had to do and who he was. He glanced quickly behind him, his legs not wanting to give up. He saw that the men began to linger, and they were no longer chasing him. Freedom, he thought. Then the trees began to lighten up. The woods weren’t as dense any more. His heart was racing, on an adrenaline rush. However, he wasn’t out of breath. His kind just didn’t do that.
Then he heard a motor, and Ethan started to get nervous. He began to quicken his pace, willing his legs faster and faster. He was almost there, almost. The motor got louder, but he wouldn’t let himself look back. He’d given up too much for this. The car, or so he assumed that was what it was, began getting closer. Ethan could feel it. It was closing in on him now and he heard shots. He hoped the bullets wouldn’t hit him. It couldn’t end like this. Unfortunately, though, the moon wasn’t out, and he could hardly see. That was the only thing his kind hadn't been blessed with. Good eyesight.
Finally, just like that, he came to a clearing out of nowhere. He was glad. Upon instinct, like always, he took off. He let the wind and cool night airflow beneath his wings. He was a brilliant sight.
However, it wasn’t enough. He wasn’t quick enough. They had hit him. He cursed himself, but found it harder and harder to think. He wanted to sleep; to just drift away...
He hit the ground with a thud, and immediately heard people around him. He yelled in an agonizing scream. The pain was so much. As he faded away, he heard shouts, and more shots.
“Ethan…Ethan. Ethan, honey, wake up!”
It was all a dream.
Chapter 1
Rate This Work
Discussion
I really liked your prologue and read Chapter One. But since you have posted a lot of content I'll offer my thoughts on your prologue. Your descriptions are great and your sense of action is also excellent Everything was pretty straight forward in that department. In other words I wasn't getting lost. One thing that however jumped out to me was the word family in quotation marks, found in the last sentence of your second paragraph:
After all, these men had hunted him and his “family” for years.
Are you referring to an earthly family of some sort or another type of family, a la a family of angels? And the ambiguity of the type of family is expanded when you mention in your forth paragraph:
They were his brothers and his family
Is this a fraternity instead of a family. If you are simply referring to brothers, then the word fraternity may in fact be more appropriate than family. And if you use fraternity, it adds a sort of mystical element to the story. My suggestion is to replace family in your last sentence of the second paragraph with fraternity. And you needn't use quotation marks for this word either. It's just a little too awkward.
I was wondering, after I realized this scene was all a dream, whether or not this dream is purely symbolic or if it is an actual event you will catch up to later. The technique I'm referring to is En Media Res, which basically plops readers into the middle of the story. Not that this is a bad thing. In fact, that is exactly how I began my story. But anyways, this ambiguity, with regards to whether this prologue; is it a symbolic vision for our friend Ethan, or an actual situation that Ethan will find himself in later in the story?
Something I really liked about your story was the closing sentence of your sixth paragraph:
His kind just didn’t do that
You are alluding to an angel I presume, the word "kind" referring to angels. While I'm not asking you to reveal the rest of your story, I just wanted to say that this sentence is perfect for placing Ethan in a light different from human beings. The only question I have is, was Ethan an angel all along, based on my reading of Chapter One, or does he turn into an angel at some point in the story. These are not critical questions, but rather a set of questions that I believe get readers interested in the story. The fact that they are asking questions means that they are willing to turn the pages. That is something that many writers have a difficult time accomplishing. Keep it up man.
One final suggestion I have is quite small and just a minor qualm of mine most like likely. You write:
“Ethan…Ethan. Ethan, honey, wake up!”
You are already implying that Ethan was dreaming. Writing "it was all a dream" is superfluous and not particularly necessary. Adding this simply makes things a little redundant. But this aside there is not much else wrong with this story. Of course I will add more critiques as I go along. But as a closing tip, keep an eye out for things that are redundant. In other words, if you're already implying something there is no need to describe it any further. It takes away from the subtlety of the story and subtlety is something that I think is what keeps readers in the mystery of the story. Just a suggestion of. Use it as you see fit. Keep up the work man. Plan on reading more soon.



Vinny,
I took a look at your Prologue and Chapter 1, and I will continue to look at more when I get a chance. I figured you could use some feedback along the way.
This isn't verbatim, but "dark and stormy night" is the oldest cliche in the book, so anything similar to it is probably bad.
Leaves aren't innately fragrant. Specify what type of leaf/plant.
This is just an example of "cluttery" language. It sounds find spoken aloud. But on the page, the repetition of "did" and "know" get in the way of the reader's ability to see action.
If the protagonist isn't human, the reader probably needs to be told for certain what he/she is-- and very soon.
"They" refers to "them men" in one sentence. But in the next sentence, "They" is used to refer to "them" (who are killed). This can get confusing to a reader.
This sentence is close to being oxymoronic.
This is better. Although "He watched" is unnecessary because "watch" is a slow verb to use in a situation where he's running.
I didn't understand this.
How can he see this? At what distance is he?
This is an explanation. Try to give an image.
If he's not human, does he have a limbic and respiratory system? These rules and violations of rules can get distracting.
I'm noticing a lot of "turnovers" at the end of paragraphs, where you turn-over an argument set forth in the beginning of the paragraph.(ex. " ____ ____ ____ but that's not the case. _____" ) Since I don't know who/what he is, these turnover refutations started to distract me and as a result I'd just skip them.
The inclusion of "just like that" adds a removed narrative voice. Why not just begin the paragraph "He came to a clearing..."?
Also, "He was a brilliant sight" is actually a POV violation because he can't see himself and therefore cannot conclude that he is brilliant-looking.
This is also written in omniscient POV, which violates the perspective taken in the prior portion of the prologue.
At the start of Chapter 1, I wanted more setting established. We see him look around his room. But is it day/night? More about time/place, and other things to give hints about his age, his world, would be helpful in this paragraph.
"slightly sarcastic" works like an adverb here. Adverbs can almost always be omitted.
This is explanation that comes in the middle of a scene of action. It feels "explainy" to me because it interrupts the flow of plot.
I had the same issue here.
This is choreography that I don't think necessarily contributes to the plot or mood. In a film, this description would be fine, but in prose it can get in the way.
"She left... with a sigh of relief from Ethan" - this can't be combined in the same sentence, because "She" and "Ethan" are both trying to be the subject.
I didn't understand the point of including this.
If you want to name "Vincent" here, I'd like to be given a sentence giving some hint as to his significance.
I think he's glad he doesn't have wings, correct? This hook should be a little more overt.
I feel there's some work to be done regarding passive voice and language. A few POV violations can easily be cleaned up. Other than that, my advice is to focus on the action and heighten your sense of setting-- and limiting the interjection of explanations. We don't want to be explained anything this early. In a prologue/first chapter, we want something to hook us into the story. Hope all of this helps thus far.