« Back to xvermonter's profile
All Critiques and Comments
Showing 21 of 22 critiques and comments.
On Clarity, by Jaya Huprikar: I don't know much about poetry and even less about haiku,
but I liked reading the work you did here.
And I don'... » Read more...
On Alleymen, by Jack McFie: I very much like this work. Some of it has me a bit
befuddled but all in all I think I understand, so let me para... » Read more...
On Digging for Potatoes, by J.K. Lynn: This is very good work. I really thought it was
written by someone who served and was a prisoner in WWII until I
... » Read more...
On Breath of Life, by Laurie Paulsen: Opening Comments
Good work.
Plot
This is what I learned from reading your first two
pages.
Brian is s... » Read more...
On Rose Rising, Chapter 1, by Laurie Paulsen: Wow. This is the kind of book I am always looking
for at the book sales, the library or Barnes & Noble.
You b... » Read more...
On The House at the end of the Lane, by Debbie Kerr: This is a fine piece of writing. You've
captured wonderful character descriptions in your snapshots.&nb... » Read more...
On Taking Time, by Eli Hart: I like this poem too. It's got a nice rhythm to it
and I like the sentiment. The poem reminds me of my ... » Read more...
On Because of You, by Lilli: This work is lovely.
It is a beautiful song of unending praise (for those of us
who hold faith) and a wonderful tha... » Read more...
On Musings (working title), Chapter 1, by Fainne Grant:
I think your rewrite of the proglogue is very good. I
enjoyed reading it. You've taken away much of th... » Read more...
On Immortal Child, Chapter 1: Playing Games, by Phedre: Good grief, this whole is
so unsettling!
My only thought - because the comments I ... » Read more...
On Even My Dust, by William Craig:
Yes, I agree very romantic. I was taken with the line
but even my dust will love
you
very crea... » Read more...
On Always Room for Jello, by Phedre: On my honor, I will never again eat jello or use gelatin
powder to make a fruit salad again. I learned ... » Read more...
On Fate or Faith?, by scholar: Well done. You questions are fundamental. I am
reminded of Doubting Thomas; he who did not belie... » Read more...
On Void, by dreamchaser:
Your work captures the feeling of lonliness that I all
experience from time to time.
I'm glad you foun... » Read more...
On Musings (working title), Chapter 1, by Fainne Grant: You have an interesting beginning here.
With the descriptive words you are using to describe your MC's
't... » Read more...
On Red Meat, by Michael Bermudez: Opening Comments
What a tale!
I didn't find it difficult to dislike Harold. I
thought Glor... » Read more...
On When Friends Return, by Aleki Suibhne: Oh yes! I like this rewrite.
Now I get it! You've provided her with the will
to ... » Read more...
On When Friends Return, by Aleki Suibhne: I read this piece several times. Your heroine and
her recurrent illness strike a chord with me, especially the
followin... » Read more...
On Poddle Stumper, by Ben Jacobson: I appreciate the O'Henry surprise ending you
have written.
I will never go out to view t... » Read more...
On A Fixed Match, by Kieran Thomson: Wow, this is strong stuff. I was a little taken
aback by the first few lines; perhaps a couple too many dashes fo... » Read more...
On Good-bye Papa, by Louise Kuskovski:
My daughter's husband died last summer leaving two very young
children (ages 3 and 1). Reading this work bro... » Read more...




